There is high demand for renting self storage units in Islip, NY. Reserve your unit today.

View 72 Safe Storage Rentals Near Islip, NY

Sort by:
72 Safe Storage Rentals Near You in Islip, NY : Showing 1 - 40 of 72
Public Storage - Bay Shore - 122 Saxon A...
Bay Shore NY 11706 | 1.20 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
SecureSpace Self Storage Deer Park
Deer Park NY 11729 | 6.00 miles away
5' x 5'
9' x 5'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 4281 - Bay Shore -...
Bay Shore NY 11706 | 3.40 miles away
5' x 5'
10' x 5'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 7569 - Bay Shore -...
Bay Shore NY 11706 | 3.70 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 4124 - North Babyl...
North Babylon NY 11703 | 5.70 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Bellport - 73 Horsebloc...
Bellport NY 11713 | 14.50 miles away
5' x 5'
$1 first month rent
10' x 5'
$1 first month rent
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 7204 - Islandia - ...
Islandia NY 11749 | 5.10 miles away
6' x 8'
10' x 10'
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Huntington Station - 67...
Huntington Station NY 11746 | 11.60 miles away
5' x 5'
$1 first month rent
5' x 10'
$1 first month rent
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 4167 - Islip - Mof...
Islip NY 11751 | 0.40 miles away
10' x 5'
10' x 10'
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Patchogue - 601 W Sunri...
Patchogue NY 11772 | 9.40 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
50% off 1st Month
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Hauppauge - 745 Old Wil...
Hauppauge NY 11788 | 5.60 miles away
5' x 5'
$1 first month rent
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 6965 - Copiague - ...
Copiague NY 11726 | 10.10 miles away
5' x 5'
10' x 5'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 3197 - Bay Shore -...
Bay Shore NY 11706 | 1.10 miles away
2' x 2'
10' x 5'
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Lake Ronkonkoma - 363 P...
Lake Ronkonkoma NY 11779 | 9.00 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Farmingdale - 305 Del D...
Farmingdale NY 11735 | 11.30 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Patchogue - 257 Waverly...
Patchogue NY 11772 | 10.00 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 4139 - Farmingvill...
Farmingville NY 11738 | 12.20 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Farmingville - 951 Hors...
Farmingville NY 11738 | 12.10 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Bayport - 709 Church St
Bayport NY 11705 | 8.90 miles away
5' x 5'
$1 first month rent
5' x 10'
$1 first month rent
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 6992 - Oakdale - M...
Oakdale NY 11769 | 3.70 miles away
4' x 4'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 0805 - Islandia - ...
Islandia NY 11749 | 5.50 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 1050 - Plainview -...
Plainview NY 11803 | 14.20 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 1033 - Brentwood -...
Brentwood NY 11717 | 5.50 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Melville - 965 Walt Whi...
Melville NY 11747 | 11.70 miles away
5' x 5'
10' x 5'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 0722 - East Northp...
East Northport NY 11731 | 9.50 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 3894 - Patchogue -...
Patchogue NY 11772 | 9.80 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
CubeSmart Self Storage NY Saint James Mi...
Saint James NY 11780 | 9.10 miles away
5' x 5'
40% Off and First Month Free
5' x 10'
40% Off and First Month Free
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 0674 - Hauppauge -...
Hauppauge NY 11788 | 5.70 miles away
5' x 10'
10' x 10'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 6692 - Oakdale - S...
Oakdale NY 11769 | 3.90 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Coram - 544 Middle Coun...
Coram NY 11727 | 14.10 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Lindenhurst - 1070 Rout...
Lindenhurst NY 11757 | 9.80 miles away
5' x 5'
50% off 1st Month
10' x 5'
50% off 1st Month
View All Sizes
Public Storage - West Babylon - 821 Sunr...
West Babylon NY 11704 | 6.70 miles away
10' x 5'
50% off 1st Month
10' x 10'
$1 first month rent
View All Sizes
Need help or want to book?
Call us 24 hours a day, 7 days a week
(866) 643-9328

Is Islip, NY Safe for Self Storage? Key Factors & Tips

There are 50 self storage facilities in Islip, NY in a 15 mile radius to choose from with over 260 units available for rent

Using $1.00 per sqft as a national average, the average price for a self storage unit is $1.52 per sqft. This is 52.20% higher with $0.52 net increase in cost per square foot. You'll be paying more in medium to large cities as storage prices are generally higher in densely populated areas.

If storage near Islip, New York is not close enough to you, you may be interested in the 15 nearby cities including Amityville, Bay Shore, Bay Shore, Bayport, Bayport, Centereach, Centereach, Central Islip, Central Islip, Central Islip, Deer Park, Deer Park, Farmingdale, Hauppauge, Hauppauge.

Islip, NY, located on Long Island, is considered a relatively safe area compared to other cities in New York State. While it is not the safest, it maintains a moderate safety rating, making it a viable option for self-storage needs. Below is a detailed analysis of factors influencing the safety and suitability of Islip for self-storage.

  • Crime Rates:

    • Islip has a lower crime rate compared to larger cities like New York City and Buffalo.
    • Violent crime rates are below the national average, contributing to its safety rating.
    • Property crimes, which are more relevant to self-storage, are moderate but manageable with proper security measures.
  • Laws and Regulations:

    • New York State has stringent laws regarding property protection, which can benefit self-storage facilities.
    • There are specific regulations for self-storage operations, ensuring consumer protection and business accountability.
  • Population Density:

    • Islip has a moderate population density, which can influence crime rates and demand for storage units.
    • Higher density areas may see increased demand for storage but also potential for higher crime rates.
  • Immediate and Surrounding Areas:

    • Islip is surrounded by other relatively safe towns and communities, such as Bay Shore and East Islip.
    • Proximity to larger urban areas like New York City can influence crime trends but also offers economic benefits.
  • Relevance to Self-Storage Industry:

    • Moderate crime rates suggest the need for robust security measures in self-storage facilities, such as surveillance cameras and gated access.
    • Demand for self-storage is supported by residential and commercial needs, given the town's population and business activities.
    • Location near major highways and transportation hubs can enhance accessibility for storage users.

Overall, Islip, NY, offers a balanced environment for self-storage operations, with moderate safety concerns that can be mitigated through effective security measures. Its strategic location and population characteristics make it a practical choice for both residents and businesses seeking storage solutions.

Islip, NY Self Storage Prices: Current Rates & Averages (Updated as of 01/29/2026)

Unit SizeAverage PriceLowest Price
5' x 5'$47.27$15.00
5' x 10'$80.83$25.00
10' x 10'$151.24$75.00
10' x 15'$227.29$134.00
20' x 10'$293.28$99.00

FAQs About Self Storage in Islip

How many storage facilities are there in Islip, NY?
There are 50 self storage facilities within a 15 mile radius of Islip, NY.
What is the average price per square foot of a storage unit in Islip, NY?
$167.45 per sq ft is the average in Islip, NY.
Do you require a deposit to register for a storage unit on safestoragerentals.com?
No, all reservations for units in Islip, NY on safestoragerentals.com are free of charge, a credit card is not required. You can reserve multiple units and then decide when you arrive at the facility.
What is the cheapest storage unit available in Islip, NY that is big enough for a 2 bedroom house?
The 10' X 15' storage unit should be good enough for a 2 bedroom house. There are 18 of these units available, as low as $134.00 per month.
What is the safest area in the greater Islip, NY area?
The safest area in the Metro Islip Area is Bay Shore.