We are experiencing high demand and can’t guarantee availability tomorrow. Reserve today with free cancellations.

View 27 Safe Storage Rentals Near Buffalo, NY

Sort by:
27 Safe Storage Rentals Near You in Buffalo, NY : Showing 1 - 27 of 27

Buffalo, NY Safety Score: 6/10

Perhaps known best for its cold weather and invention of the Buffalo wing, Buffalo, New York is a more dynamic and exciting city than it often gets credit for. The economy has diversified since the city’s industrial days with a lot of tourist and logistics companies taking advantage of the city’s border with Canada. After work, residents enjoy spending time in the oldest urban parks system in the US and cheering on the long-suffering Bills of the NFL and Sabres of the NHL.

While rents and home prices are lower in Buffalo than in the rest of the country, rents are up 3% from the past year and house prices are up 30%. And with the population growing, housing stocks are low. Moving to Buffalo might mean waiting for a good property to come on the market or settling for less storage space than you might like.

Thankfully, there are plenty of self-storage facilities in Buffalo that can help make your move easier. Even if need a larger unit, you’ll be surprised by how affordable it can be. And with facilities all over town, it’s convenient, too. If you’re thinking of a move to Buffalo, don’t let storage space be what holds you back.

more
Advantage Self Storage - Depew
Depew NY 14043 | 7.80 miles away
5' x 5'
$1 Pays 1st Month's Rent
5' x 10'
$1 Pays 1st Month's Rent
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 6525 - Hamburg - S...
Hamburg NY 14075 | 8.80 miles away
10' x 5'
10' x 10'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 3245 - West Seneca...
West Seneca NY 14224 | 9.60 miles away
5' x 10'
10' x 10'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 3246 - Blasdell - ...
Blasdell NY 14219 | 7.00 miles away
5' x 10'
10' x 10'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 3247 - Cheektowaga...
Cheektowaga NY 14227 | 6.30 miles away
5' x 10'
10' x 10'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 3020 - Williamsvil...
Williamsville NY 14221 | 10.90 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 4237 - Depew - Fre...
Depew NY 14043 | 9.10 miles away
10' x 5'
10' x 10'
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Tonawanda - 105 Hospita...
Tonawanda NY 14150 | 7.70 miles away
5' x 10'
10' x 10'
50% off 1st Month
View All Sizes
Public Storage - West Seneca - 1300 Sout...
West Seneca NY 14224 | 9.50 miles away
5' x 10'
10' x 10'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 3009 - Cheektowaga...
Cheektowaga NY 14225 | 7.10 miles away
10' x 10'
View All Sizes
LocalStorage Hamburg
Hamburg NY 14075 | 9.80 miles away
10' x 10'
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Lancaster - 3953 Walden...
Lancaster NY 14086 | 12.00 miles away
5' x 10'
50% off 1st Month
10' x 10'
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Amherst - 2855 Niagara ...
Amherst NY 14228 | 10.50 miles away
5' x 10'
10' x 10'
50% off 1st Month
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Getzville - 2750 Miller...
Getzville NY 14068 | 11.00 miles away
5' x 10'
10' x 10'
$1 first month rent
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 3434 - Buffalo - C...
Buffalo NY 14225 | 7.90 miles away
10' x 10'
View All Sizes
Public Storage - Williamsville - 4871 Tr...
Williamsville NY 14221 | 11.30 miles away
5' x 5'
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
LocalStorage Lake View
Lake View NY 14085 | 12.40 miles away
10' x 15'
View All Sizes
Extra Space Storage - 3737 - Orchard Par...
Orchard Park NY 14127 | 10.40 miles away
5' x 5'
10' x 5'
View All Sizes
Jeff's Attic @ Plaza Dr
Niagara Falls NY 14304 | 14.50 miles away
10' x 20'
View All Sizes
Need help or want to book?
Call us 24 hours a day, 7 days a week
(866) 643-9328

Is Buffalo, NY Safe for Self Storage? Key Factors & Tips

There are 16 self storage facilities in Buffalo, NY in a 15 mile radius to choose from with up to 83 storage units, you may find cheaper storage prices in Buffalo comparable to the national average price.

Using $1.00 per sqft as a national average, the average price for a self storage unit is $1.34 per sqft. This is 33.81% higher with $0.34 net increase in cost per square foot. You'll be paying more in medium to large cities as storage prices are generally higher in densely populated areas.

If storage near Buffalo, New York is not close enough to you, you may be interested in the 11 nearby cities including Alden, Cheektowaga, Clarence, Depew, Eden, Hamburg, Niagara Falls, North Tonawanda, Tonawanda, West Seneca, Williamsville.

Buffalo, NY, is a city with a diverse range of neighborhoods, each with its own unique characteristics and safety levels. When considering the safety of self-storage facilities in Buffalo, several factors come into play, including crime rates, population density, and the surrounding areas. Here is a detailed analysis of these factors to provide a comprehensive understanding of the safety of self-storage in Buffalo, NY.

  • Crime Rates:

    • Buffalo has a higher crime rate compared to many other cities in New York State, particularly in terms of property crimes, which are a significant concern for self-storage facilities.
    • Violent crime rates are also above the national average, though they have been decreasing in recent years.
    • Specific neighborhoods may have varying crime rates, with some areas being safer than others.
  • Laws and Regulations:

    • New York State has stringent laws regarding the operation of self-storage facilities, including requirements for security measures such as surveillance cameras and secure access systems.
    • Buffalo city ordinances may impose additional regulations to enhance safety and security at storage facilities.
  • Population Density:

    • Buffalo has a moderate population density, which can impact the demand and security needs of self-storage facilities.
    • Higher population density areas may experience more frequent use of storage units, potentially increasing the risk of theft or vandalism.
  • Immediate and Surrounding Areas:

    • The safety of a self-storage facility can be influenced by its immediate surroundings, including the presence of businesses, residential areas, and public transportation.
    • Facilities located in well-lit, busy areas may deter criminal activity compared to those in more isolated locations.
    • Proximity to law enforcement or security services can also enhance the safety of a storage facility.
  • Considerations for Self-Storage Renters:

    • When choosing a self-storage facility in Buffalo, consider the security measures in place, such as gated access, surveillance cameras, and on-site personnel.
    • Evaluate the facility's location and its reputation within the community for safety and reliability.
    • Consider insurance options for stored items to protect against potential theft or damage.

In summary, while Buffalo, NY, presents some challenges in terms of crime rates and safety, there are measures that both self-storage operators and renters can take to mitigate risks. By carefully selecting facilities with robust security features and considering the surrounding environment, renters can enhance the safety of their stored belongings. Overall, Buffalo receives a safety rating of 6 out of 10 for self-storage, indicating a moderate level of safety with room for improvement through strategic choices and adherence to safety practices.

Buffalo, NY Self Storage Prices: Current Rates & Averages (Updated as of 05/06/2026)

Unit SizeAverage PriceLowest Price
5' x 5'$71.50$32.00
5' x 10'$82.20$49.00
10' x 10'$127.45$85.00
15' x 10'$219.10$111.00
20' x 10'$216.08$170.00

FAQs About Self Storage in Buffalo

How many storage facilities are there in Buffalo, NY?
There are 16 self storage facilities within a 15 mile radius of Buffalo, NY.
What is the average price per square foot of a storage unit in Buffalo, NY?
$157.48 per sq ft is the average in Buffalo, NY.
Do you require a deposit to register for a storage unit on safestoragerentals.com?
No, all reservations for units in Buffalo, NY on safestoragerentals.com are free of charge, a credit card is not required. You can reserve multiple units and then decide when you arrive at the facility.
What is the cheapest storage unit available in Buffalo, NY that is big enough for a 2 bedroom house?
The 10' X 15' storage unit should be good enough for a 2 bedroom house. There are 11 of these units available, as low as $111.00 per month.
What is the safest area in the greater Buffalo, NY area?
The safest area in the Metro Buffalo Area is Elmwood Village.