We are experiencing high demand and can’t guarantee availability tomorrow. Reserve today with free cancellations.

View 7 Safe Storage Rentals Near Middlebury, IN 46540

Sort by:
7 Safe Storage Rentals Near You in Middlebury, IN : Showing 1 - 7 of 7
Heartland Storage - Sturgis - 69004 Klin...
Sturgis MI 49091 | 12.40 miles away
5' x 10'
First Month’s Rent: $0
10' x 10'
First Month’s Rent: $0
View All Sizes
Heartland Storage - Sturgis - 25040 US-1...
Sturgis MI 49091 | 14.90 miles away
5' x 10'
First Month’s Rent: $0
10' x 10'
First Month’s Rent: $0
View All Sizes
Shine Star Self Storage
Elkhart IN 46516 | 12.10 miles away
5' x 10'
First Months Rent Free !
10' x 10'
First Months Rent Free !
View All Sizes
Forest Creek Self Storage
Elkhart IN 46517 | 13.00 miles away
5' x 10'
View All Sizes
Need help or want to book?
Call us 24 hours a day, 7 days a week
(866) 643-9328

Middlebury, IN Safety Rating for Self-Storage: 8/10

Middlebury, Indiana, is considered a relatively safe town, especially when compared to other cities in the state. This makes it a favorable location for self-storage facilities. Here is a detailed analysis of the factors contributing to its safety rating:

  • Crime Rates:
    • Middlebury has a lower crime rate compared to the state average, with fewer incidents of violent and property crimes.
    • The town's crime rate is significantly below the national average, contributing to its reputation as a safe community.
    • Local law enforcement is proactive in community policing, which helps maintain low crime levels.
  • Laws and Regulations:
    • Indiana has robust laws regarding property protection, which extends to self-storage units.
    • Middlebury follows state regulations that ensure the security and privacy of storage renters.
    • Local ordinances support business operations, including self-storage, by maintaining a safe and business-friendly environment.
  • Population Density:
    • Middlebury is a small town with a population of approximately 3,500 people, contributing to a tight-knit community atmosphere.
    • The low population density reduces the likelihood of crime, making it a safer place for self-storage facilities.
    • Residents are more likely to know each other, which can deter criminal activity.
  • Immediate and Surrounding Areas:
    • Middlebury is located in Elkhart County, which is known for its safe and family-friendly communities.
    • The town is surrounded by rural areas and small towns, which generally have lower crime rates than urban centers.
    • Nearby cities, such as Goshen and Elkhart, offer additional amenities and services, enhancing the quality of life in Middlebury.
  • Relevance to Self-Storage Industry:
    • The low crime rate and strong community ties make Middlebury an attractive location for self-storage businesses.
    • Potential customers may feel more secure renting storage units in a town with a reputation for safety.
    • Storage facilities can benefit from lower insurance premiums due to the reduced risk of theft and vandalism.
    • Proximity to major highways and neighboring cities increases accessibility for customers from surrounding areas.

Overall, Middlebury's combination of low crime rates, supportive laws, and a close-knit community make it a safe and appealing location for self-storage facilities. With an 8/10 safety rating, it stands out as a secure choice for individuals and businesses looking to rent storage units in Indiana.

Self Storage Prices in Middlebury, IN

Unit SizeAverage PriceLowest Price
5' x 5'$94.40$31.00
5' x 10'$40.50$20.00
10' x 10'$88.10$38.00
10' x 15'$96.09$50.00
10' x 20'$104.44$66.00
Pricing updated on 10/16/2025

FAQs About Self Storage in Middlebury

How many storage facilities are there in Middlebury, IN?
There are 6 self storage facilities within a 15 mile radius of Middlebury, IN.
What is the average price per square foot of a storage unit in Middlebury, IN?
$97.15 per sq ft is the average in Middlebury, IN.
Do you require a deposit to register for a storage unit on safestoragerentals.com?
No, all reservations for units in Middlebury, IN on safestoragerentals.com are free of charge, a credit card is not required. You can reserve multiple units and then decide when you arrive at the facility.
What is the cheapest storage unit available in Middlebury, IN that is big enough for a 2 bedroom house?
The 10' X 15' storage unit should be good enough for a 2 bedroom house. There are 11 of these units available, as low as $50.00 per month.
What is the safest area in the greater Middlebury, IN area?
The safest area in the Metro Middlebury Area is York Township.
Search National Self Storage Facility Locations